Glossary
APY includes compounding; APR does not. Crypto marketing quotes APY because the number is bigger - and the compounding usually only happens if you manually re-stake, which is a taxable event each time you do it.
APR (annual percentage rate) is a simple rate: 10 percent APR on $1,000 pays $100 over a year with no compounding. APY (annual percentage yield) is the rate including compounding: 10 percent compounded daily produces about $105, because each payment earns its own return for the rest of the year. The formula is APY equals (1 plus r over n) to the power of n, minus 1, where r is the rate and n is the number of compounding periods.
Crypto marketing prefers APY because the number is bigger, and the gap widens with the rate: 100 percent APR compounded daily is about 172 percent APY. The detail that matters is that the compounding is usually your job. Most protocols pay rewards in tokens on a schedule; they do not re-stake them for you. The APY on the dashboard assumes you convert and re-stake every payment, which is a transaction with fees and, under ATO guidance, a taxable event each time.
For Australian readers, the honest comparison is against a savings account: the best Australian savings rates pay around 5 percent, paid monthly, in dollars, with the Financial Claims Scheme behind deposits up to $250,000. A crypto APY is paid in a token that can halve, with no protection scheme, and the compounding needs manual work and records.
The formula is APY equals (1 plus r over n) to the power of n, minus 1. With r at 10 percent and daily compounding, n is 365, and APY works out to about 10.5 percent. With r at 100 percent, the same daily compounding produces about 172 percent. The more frequent the compounding, the larger the APY at the same APR, which is why dashboards quote APY: it is the same product with a bigger number on the label.
Walk through one year and the mechanics become practical. You deposit $5,000 AUD into a protocol advertising 40 percent APY, compounded daily. If the compounding worked as advertised, the position ends the year near $7,000.
In practice the protocol drips rewards weekly in its own token, worth roughly $38 AUD per drip at the entry price. Re-staking each drip costs a transaction - fees of a few dollars on Ethereum, less on cheaper networks - and each conversion is a taxable event under ATO guidance. If the reward token halves over the year, the real yield lands near 20 percent - about $1,000 AUD - and the compounding the APY promised happened only if you paid for it weekly.
The APY-versus-APR gap is the headline-yield illusion, and it is everywhere an Australian looks at crypto yields. The dashboard quotes the bigger number, the compounding is your unpaid job, and the rewards are paid in a token whose price is the actual yield. ASIC MoneySmart's guidance warns that advertised returns are not guaranteed - and a crypto APY is the least guaranteed return in finance.
A colleague named Brent (yes, that Brent) compared a 40 percent APY farm against a 6 percent savings account. He ignored that the farm paid in a falling token, and never re-staked. He earned roughly half the headline for the year, paid transaction fees on the drips he did convert, and owed income tax on every reward at its value when received.
The highest-leverage thing most Australians can do is convert every yield quote to its real terms before comparing: the rate, the token it is paid in, and the work the compounding requires. Read the staking entry for the tax mechanics of rewards, and the yield-farming entry for the risk stack underneath a farm's headline.
You deposit $5,000 AUD into a protocol advertising 40 percent APY. Advertised, the position ends the year near $7,000. In practice the rewards drip weekly in the protocol's token, worth roughly $38 AUD per drip at entry, and re-staking each one costs a few dollars of fees. If the token halves over the year, the real yield is roughly 20 percent - about $1,000 AUD - while the headline still reads 40, and every reward was assessable income at its value when received.
You hold $10,000 AUD of stablecoin in a protocol paying 10 percent APR. Left alone, the position earns $1,000 over the year. Re-stake each monthly payment as it lands and the compounding lifts the yield to about 10.5 percent - roughly $1,047. The extra $47 cost twenty transactions of fees and records under ATO guidance, which is the compounding the APY assumes you are doing.
The best Australian savings accounts pay around 5 percent, paid monthly in dollars, with the Financial Claims Scheme covering deposits up to $250,000. A crypto protocol paying 40 percent APY in a volatile token is not the same product with a better rate - it is a different product with four risk layers and no protection scheme. Check the live Ethereum price before assuming any token-denominated yield holds its value.
Mistake: Comparing a crypto APY against a savings rate as if they were the same product.
Why it bites you: The savings account pays in dollars with the FCS behind it; the APY pays in a token that can halve, with no protection. Brent's 40-versus-6 comparison was apples against a falling apple tree.
Mistake: Assuming the protocol compounds for you.
Why it bites you: Most protocols pay rewards in tokens and leave the re-staking to you. Without manual re-staking you earn closer to the APR, and the APY on the dashboard was never your yield.
Mistake: Re-staking every drip without counting the fees and tax.
Why it bites you: Each conversion is a transaction and a taxable event under ATO guidance. Twenty re-stakes cost fees plus a year of records, which can exceed the compounding benefit at small balances.
Mistake: Believing the APY holds while the reward token falls.
Why it bites you: The headline is fixed in percentage terms; the rewards are fixed in token terms. A token halving halves the real yield while the dashboard keeps advertising the original number.
I spent an evening running the compounding formula across every rate and frequency combination so you do not have to, and the summary is that APY is APR wearing a bigger number to the interview. The gap is real arithmetic, and the arithmetic assumes you work for free. Re-stake every drip, pay the fees, keep the records, and hope the reward token holds its value - that is the product the dashboard is quoting.
The useful version is mechanical: convert every yield to its real terms before comparing it to anything in dollars, and treat the compounding as a cost centre rather than a feature. I ran one year of drips through the fee and tax maths so you do not have to, and at small balances the compounding is worth less than the paperwork. The headline is a label. Read the ingredients.
Neither is better - they are two labels for the same product, and APY is bigger because it includes compounding. The useful question is whether the compounding actually happens, which in crypto is usually your job.
Because the number is bigger, and the gap widens with the rate - 100 percent APR compounded daily is about 172 percent APY. The dashboard quote assumes you re-stake every reward, which costs fees and creates tax events.
The ATO does not tax the advertised rate - it taxes each reward as assessable income at its AUD market value when received, with the reward also a CGT asset from that moment. Your records, not the dashboard, determine the tax.
No. ASIC MoneySmart warns that advertised returns are not guaranteed, and a crypto APY is paid in a token whose price can halve while the headline stays unchanged. It is the least guaranteed yield in finance.
As often as you re-stake them. Protocols drip rewards on schedules ranging from continuous to weekly, and the compounding the APY assumes only happens if you convert and redeposit each drip, paying fees and creating records each time.
Disclaimer: This information is general in nature and does not constitute financial or legal advice. Always consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.

Financial Chaos Analyst
Ivy Sinclair-Wren is a Financial Chaos Analyst covering crypto markets, investing behaviour, and the Australian habit of checking prices during family dinners. Based in Melbourne, she reviews AUD Crypto Tracker's coin guides for accuracy, ATO alignment, and ruthless utility — no hype, no predictions, just what the data says.