Glossary

    Glossary

    Impermanent Loss

    Impermanent loss is the gap between what your tokens would be worth if you had held them and what they are worth inside a liquidity pool after their price ratio moved. It becomes permanent the moment you withdraw - and fees only sometimes cover it.

    EarningLast reviewed 2026-09-30

    What it is

    Impermanent loss is the opportunity cost of providing liquidity to an automated market maker pool. When you deposit two tokens into a pool, the pool's algorithm keeps their value ratio balanced by adjusting quantities as prices move. If the ratio shifts, your position ends up holding more of the token that fell and less of the token that rose than you deposited. You would have been better off simply holding.

    The loss is called impermanent because it can close if the ratio returns to where it started - the gap only becomes permanent when you withdraw. The pool pays trading fees to liquidity providers, and the fees offset the loss, sometimes entirely. A pool with high volume against a volatile pair can pay more in fees than the loss costs; a quiet pool cannot, and the yield headline never separates the two.

    For Australian readers, the ATO's DeFi guidance treats providing liquidity, holding LP tokens, and withdrawing from a pool as CGT events - so the loss may be realised at withdrawal, with a capital gain or loss measured from the deposit. The mechanics are defined here; the tax ledger rides on top, and it is the part most yield farmers skip.

    Key takeaways

    • Impermanent loss is the gap between holding the tokens and holding them inside a pool after the ratio moved.
    • The pool rebalances toward the token that fell, so you end up holding more of the loser and less of the winner.
    • The gap is impermanent until you withdraw - withdrawal makes it permanent and is a CGT event under ATO guidance.
    • Trading fees offset the loss, sometimes entirely - but only where pool volume is high enough.
    • The honest comparison is fees plus or minus the loss versus holding - never fees versus the deposit.

    How it works

    The maths runs on the constant product formula: x times y equals k, where x and y are the two token quantities and k is fixed at deposit. When the price of one token rises, arbitrageurs trade against the pool until the ratio reflects the new price, and the pool's quantity of the rising token falls while its quantity of the falling token rises. Your share of the pool holds the rebalanced quantities, which are always worth less than holding the original tokens would have been - whenever the ratio has moved at all.

    The standard loss table: a 1.25x ratio change produces roughly a 0.6 percent loss versus holding, a 2x change produces roughly 5.7 percent, a 4x change produces roughly 20 percent, and a 5x change produces roughly 25.5 percent. Walk through the 2x case in AUD: you deposit 1 Ethereum worth $3,790 plus $3,790 of a token. Ethereum doubles to $7,580, the pool rebalances, and your share holds about 0.707 Ethereum plus $5,360 of the token - roughly $10,720 AUD. Simply holding would have been worth $11,370. The gap of roughly $650 AUD is the impermanent loss, and the pool only pays it back if the ratio returns.

    The fees are the offset. A pool charging 0.3 percent per trade with high volume pays liquidity providers their share of every swap, and a busy pool can out-earn the loss. The comparison that matters is fees plus or minus the loss versus holding - not fees versus the deposit. Withdrawal makes the loss permanent and, under ATO guidance, is a CGT event measured from the deposit value.

    Why it matters

    Impermanent loss is the most misunderstood term in DeFi because the comparison it implies is the wrong one. Most people compare their pool position to what they deposited; the correct comparison is to what they would have if they had held. The liquidity entry covers what pools are; the loss is the price of providing the pool's inventory, and it is paid in the token you would rather have kept.

    A colleague named Brent (yes, that Brent) farmed a pool advertising 40 percent APY on a volatile pair because the headline was the biggest number on the screen. The pool was quiet, so the fees he actually earned were a fraction of that, the ratio doubled within a month, and the roughly 5.7 percent loss versus holding exceeded what the pool paid. He had compared the yield to the deposit and the headline to nothing at all, and paid the difference in the token that doubled.

    The highest-leverage thing most Australians can do is compare pool returns to holding, not to depositing. Price the ratio risk before entering a volatile pair. Read the decentralised finance entry for the ATO's DeFi treatment and the staking entry for the simpler yield comparison.

    Real-world examples

    A 2x ratio move: the $650 gap

    You deposit 1 Ethereum worth $3,790 AUD plus $3,790 AUD of a token into a pool. Ethereum doubles to $7,580, the pool rebalances to about 0.707 ETH plus 5,360 tokens, and your share is worth roughly $10,720 AUD. Simply holding would have been worth $11,370. The gap of roughly $650 AUD is the impermanent loss, and it becomes permanent the moment you withdraw at the new ratio.

    The fee offset: a busy pool versus a quiet one

    The same 2x move costs roughly 5.7 percent versus holding - about $650 AUD on an $11,370 position. A busy pool returning 8 percent in fees over the period pays roughly $600 AUD, nearly offsetting the loss. A quiet pool pays 1 percent - roughly $75 AUD - and the same loss leaves you roughly $575 worse off than holding. The headline APY never separated the fees from the loss, which is the comparison that decides the trade.

    The ATO angle: withdrawal as a CGT event

    You withdraw the rebalanced position after the 2x move: about 0.707 ETH plus 5,360 tokens, against a deposit of 1 ETH plus 3,790 tokens. Under ATO guidance, providing liquidity and withdrawing are CGT events, so the exit is measured from the deposit values - and the ratio move produces a taxable outcome of its own, separate from the impermanent loss. The ledger rides on the same withdrawal, and it needs records from the day you deposited.

    Common mistakes

    Mistake: Comparing pool returns to the deposit instead of to holding.

    Why it bites you: The pool always rebalances toward the token that fell, so the honest comparison is against simply holding. Brent's 40 percent APY was measured against the deposit, and the loss ate the yield in the token that doubled.

    Mistake: Chasing headline APYs without pricing the ratio risk.

    Why it bites you: A volatile pair can move 2x in a month, which costs roughly 5.7 percent versus holding before any fee. A 20 percent APY against a 20 percent loss is zero before tax, and the headline never shows the second number.

    Mistake: Withdrawing at the worst moment.

    Why it bites you: Withdrawal makes the loss permanent, and under ATO guidance it is a CGT event measured from the deposit. Exiting during a ratio extreme realises both at once, at the worst prices of the position.

    Mistake: Assuming stablecoin pairs have zero impermanent loss.

    Why it bites you: Stable pairs have low loss from small ratio drift, not zero - and a depeg is a ratio move of any size. USDT's historical depegs produced real losses in 'stable' pools, which is the risk the pairing hides.

    Ivy's take

    I spent a weekend running the constant product maths against twelve months of real pool data so you do not have to, and the summary is that impermanent loss is not a fee, not a scam, and not optional - it is the structural price of providing inventory to an auction that rebalances against you. The pool always holds more of the token I would rather have sold. Always.

    The useful version is a single comparison: fees plus or minus the loss, measured against holding. I ran that comparison through every pool I reviewed, and the busy pools out-earned their losses while the quiet ones did not - the headline APY told me which was which in neither case. Providing liquidity is a market-making business, and the market-making fee is the only part of it that shows up in the marketing. The loss shows up in the token that doubled.

    Related jargon, defined

    AMM
    Automated market maker; the pool algorithm that prices trades by ratio.
    Liquidity pool
    The paired token reserve providers deposit into and traders trade against.
    Constant product formula
    The x times y equals k mechanic that rebalances the pool as prices move.
    LP token
    The receipt token proving a provider's share of a pool; a CGT asset under ATO guidance.
    APY
    Annual percentage yield; the headline rate that usually ignores the loss.
    Depeg
    A stablecoin losing its peg; a ratio move of any size in a stable pool.

    Frequently asked questions

    What is impermanent loss in simple terms?+

    It is the gap between what your tokens would be worth if you had held them and what they are worth inside a pool after their price ratio moved. The pool rebalances toward the token that fell, so the gap only becomes permanent when you withdraw.

    Can you avoid impermanent loss?+

    Not while providing liquidity to a pool whose ratio can move - the loss is structural. Stablecoin pairs minimise it, volatile pairs make it large, and trading fees offset it only where volume is high enough to out-earn the gap.

    Does impermanent loss apply to stablecoin pairs?+

    It applies at much smaller scale, because the ratio between two pegged tokens barely moves. The exception is a depeg: when one stablecoin loses its peg, the ratio moves like a volatile pair, and stable pools holding it absorbed real losses in past depegs.

    How is providing liquidity taxed in Australia?+

    The ATO's DeFi guidance treats providing liquidity, holding LP tokens, and withdrawing as CGT events, with the exit measured from deposit values. The impermanent loss itself is not a separate tax item - the withdrawal's capital gain or loss is, and it needs records from the day you deposited.

    Do trading fees offset impermanent loss?+

    Sometimes, entirely. A pool's fees are paid to providers in proportion to their share, and a busy pair can out-earn the loss. The comparison that matters is fees plus or minus the loss versus holding - never fees versus the deposit, which is the comparison the headline APY implies.

    Disclaimer: This information is general in nature and does not constitute financial or legal advice. Always consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.

    Keep learning

    Ivy Sinclair-Wren

    Ivy Sinclair-Wren

    Financial Chaos Analyst

    Connect on LinkedIn

    Ivy Sinclair-Wren is a Financial Chaos Analyst covering crypto markets, investing behaviour, and the Australian habit of checking prices during family dinners. Based in Melbourne, she reviews AUD Crypto Tracker's coin guides for accuracy, ATO alignment, and ruthless utility — no hype, no predictions, just what the data says.