Glossary
NFT royalties are a creator percentage on secondary sales, typically five to ten percent. The code signals the royalty but cannot enforce it - enforcement lives with the marketplaces, and when they made royalties optional, the promise evaporated.
NFT royalties are a percentage of secondary sales paid to the creator each time a token changes hands, typically five to ten percent. The idea is that artists earn from their work's resale value the way musicians were promised streaming royalties. The mechanic is not written into the code the way a transfer is: the token's metadata can signal a royalty preference, and the marketplace decides whether to honour it.
That gap between signal and enforcement is the story. Through 2022 and 2023, the major marketplaces made royalties optional, and volumes migrated to the platforms that charged nothing. A creator's royalty is a promise enforced by whoever operates the marketplace that day, not a property of the token. For Australian creators, royalty income is ordinary income under the ATO's guidance when received; for collectors, each resale is a CGT event on the token's gain.
Walk one resale. You buy an NFT for $500 AUD and resell it later for $1,200 AUD. If the marketplace honours the royalty - say five percent - the creator receives $60 AUD of the sale, and you receive the remainder minus the platform fee. The royalty is not a transfer function: the token's metadata signals the preference, and the marketplace's code chooses whether to calculate and pay it. A marketplace that ignores the signal pays nothing, and the token itself cannot object.
The signal standard exists. An Ethereum proposal from 2018 defined a way for tokens to declare a royalty that compatible marketplaces can read. It is a standard for what can be communicated, not what must be paid - the token-standard entry covers how standards are interfaces, not enforcement.
The enforcement gap became a market event through 2022 and 2023. Large marketplaces made royalties optional, zero-royalty platforms captured volume, and creators watched the promised revenue line shrink to whatever marketplaces chose to honour. The result is the current state: royalties are honoured where marketplaces find it worthwhile and ignored where they do not, and the smart-contract entry covers why code that could enforce a split was not used.
For an Australian reader, NFT royalties are two different tax events wearing one term. If you create and sell NFTs, royalty income is ordinary income under the ATO's guidance - the staking-income-tax entry covers the ordinary-income framing that applies to earned crypto generally. If you collect, each resale is a CGT event: your $500 to $1,200 flip is taxed on the gain, and the royalty you paid may form part of the cost base depending on how the sale is structured.
A colleague named Brent (yes, that Brent) budgeted around a creator's royalty income as if it were contractual, because the marketplace page said five percent. Through 2023 the marketplaces went optional, and the income line did what optional income does. The highest-leverage thing most Australians can do is treat royalties as a market-dependent revenue share, not a contractual right - record every resale in your crypto-record-keeping files, and check the non-fungible-token entry for the token versus copyright distinction.
You buy an NFT for $500 AUD and resell it for $1,200 AUD on a marketplace honouring a five percent royalty. The creator receives $60, the platform takes its fee, and you receive the rest - a taxable gain on the difference between your buy and sell prices. The royalty was paid because the marketplace chose to, not because the token required it. On a zero-royalty platform the same sale pays you $60 more and the creator nothing.
A creator budgeted around five percent royalties on a collection's secondary volume. Through 2022 and 2023 the major marketplaces made royalties optional, volume migrated to zero-royalty platforms, and the revenue line shrank to what the remaining marketplaces honoured. The token's code signalled the royalty throughout; the signal was never the enforcement. The income is also ordinary income for the ATO, taxed at marginal rates when received.
You pay $1,200 AUD for an NFT, including a $60 royalty and a $24 platform fee. The ATO's cost-base rules generally allow costs incurred in acquiring an asset to form part of the cost base - the capital-gains-tax-crypto entry covers the rules. When you resell for $1,500, the gain is calculated against that cost base, and the discount applies if you held beyond twelve months. The royalty is a cost, the gain is the tax event.
Mistake: Treating an NFT royalty as a contractual, enforceable right.
Why it bites you: The token signals a royalty; marketplaces decide whether to pay it. The majors went optional through 2022 and 2023, and the promise followed the volume to zero.
Mistake: Budgeting a creator's royalty income as guaranteed.
Why it bites you: Optional revenue does what optional revenue does. Brent's budget assumed the marketplace page was a contract, and the income line was the lesson.
Mistake: Forgetting each NFT resale is a CGT event.
Why it bites you: The ATO taxes the gain between your buy and sell prices on every resale, royalties aside. The [capital-gains-tax-crypto entry](/glossary/capital-gains-tax-crypto/) covers the rules, and the discount needs a twelve-month hold.
Mistake: Assuming the royalty standard enforces payment.
Why it bites you: The standard is a way to communicate a preference, not to enforce it - the [token-standard entry](/glossary/token-standard/) covers the interface distinction. Code that could enforce a split was not used, which is the story.
I spent an evening reading through the royalty standard and the marketplace policy changes so you don't have to, and the summary is one sentence: the code signals, the marketplace decides, and when the marketplaces decided, the royalties went optional. The 'unenforceable code' framing is exactly right, and it is the cleanest case study in crypto for the difference between a preference and a property.
I ran the numbers through a worked flip - $500 in, $1,200 out - and the royalty's absence on a zero-fee platform was worth more to the seller than its presence ever was to the creator, which is why the volume moved. The ATO angle is dry by comparison and firm: royalty income is ordinary income, resales are CGT events, and neither cares what the marketplace promises. Treat royalties as a revenue share that the market can renegotiate at any time. Because it can.
No. The token's metadata can signal a royalty preference, but enforcement lives with the marketplace. The major marketplaces made royalties optional through 2022 and 2023, which is the gap made visible.
For creators, royalty income is ordinary income under the ATO's guidance, taxed at marginal rates when received. For collectors, each resale is a CGT event on the token's gain, separate from any royalty involved.
Because volumes migrated to zero-royalty platforms, and marketplaces followed the orders. The market voted with its fees, and creators' promised revenue shrank to what platforms chose to honour.
Generally yes, if the royalty was incurred in acquiring the asset. The ATO's cost-base rules allow incidental acquisition costs, so the royalty and platform fees on your purchase can reduce the taxable gain on resale.
Only where marketplaces honour them, which has become optional. The token's code cannot enforce the payment, so the royalty lasts exactly as long as the marketplaces find it worthwhile.
Disclaimer: This information is general in nature and does not constitute financial or legal advice. Always consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.

Financial Chaos Analyst
Ivy Sinclair-Wren is a Financial Chaos Analyst covering crypto markets, investing behaviour, and the Australian habit of checking prices during family dinners. Based in Melbourne, she reviews AUD Crypto Tracker's coin guides for accuracy, ATO alignment, and ruthless utility — no hype, no predictions, just what the data says.